Contact Us 


Are Professional Carpet Cleaners Better Than Doing It Yourself?

Published April 12, 2024 by Green Kleaning Services, LLC

carpet cleaner treating a stain


When it comes to carpet cleaning, homeowners are faced with two main choices: tackling the job themselves with a DIY approach or hiring professional carpet cleaners.

There are many benefits to hiring professionals to do the job including not having to spend alot of money on expensive carpet cleaning equipment. Also, spending the time learn the correct process and appropriate carpet cleaning solutions to clean carpets and upholstery may not be a hobby you will want to undertake unless you have a true passion for carpeting.

This takes time and while this article doesn't aim to discourage a DIY approach we present the pros and cons of each for you to make an educated decision.

Pros and Cons of DIY Carpet Cleaning

man on his knees inspecting a carpet

Pros of DIY carpet cleaners

Cost-effective: One of the most appealing aspects of DIY carpet cleaning is its cost-effectiveness. Renting a carpet cleaning machine is often more affordable than enlisting the services of a professional cleaning team.

Suitable for lightly soiled carpets: If your carpets are only minimally dirty or have just a few light stains, a DIY cleaning might do the trick without the need for more intensive professional services.

Convenience: Opting for DIY cleaning means you can schedule the job whenever it suits you, providing flexibility to work around your personal timetable.

Cons of DIY Carpet Cleaning

Ineffective cleaning: Despite the best efforts, DIY carpet cleaning machines typically lack the power to eradicate deeply embedded dirt, allergens, and the most stubborn stains, leaving behind what your eyes can't see.

Risk of damage: Incorrect use of cleaning solutions or machines can lead to carpet damage, affecting both the appearance and lifespan of your flooring.

Slow drying time: Carpets cleaned with rental equipment may not dry as quickly as those treated by professionals, increasing the risk of mold and mildew development.

Not ideal for delicate carpets: The one-size-fits-all approach of DIY cleaning solutions can be harmful to certain types of carpets, particularly those that require a gentler touch.

Pros of Professional Carpet Cleaning

carpet cleaning illustration

Deeper clean: Professional carpet cleaners bring the heat—literally. With high-powered equipment and hot water extraction techniques, they’re able to provide a level of cleanliness that DIY efforts can rarely match.

Stain and odor removal: Thanks to their expertise, professional cleaners are adept at removing tough stains and eliminating persistent odors, including those caused by pets.

Faster drying time: Professional techniques ensure carpets dry swiftly, thereby mitigating the risk of mold and mildew growth, a common pitfall of slower drying methods.

Carpet protection: Some professionals offer additional services to protect your carpets, helping them resist future soiling and extending their beauty and life.

Experienced technicians: Trained and seasoned in dealing with a variety of carpet types and cleaning challenges, professional cleaners can navigate any situation with ease.

Cons of Professional Carpet Cleaning


Cost is really the main disadvantage of professional carpet cleaning services. There's no way around it. There is some cost associated to getting your carpets, upholstery, and area rugs cleaned the right way.

Good carpet cleaning equipment and products are expensive. Along with know-how by a professional carpet cleaner to deal with various unforeseen situations is what will make all the difference in the results.

While offering numerous benefits, hiring a professional cleaning service is invariably pricier than renting a DIY machine but at the same time more cost effective than replacing carpet which can go into the hundreds or thousands of dollars.

Making the Decision: DIY vs. A Professional Carpet Cleaning Service

When it comes to maintaining the freshness and cleanliness of your carpets, the dilemma between embarking on a DIY cleaning project or calling in the professionals is a common one. This decision can significantly impact not just the appearance and longevity of your carpets, but also the health and comfort of your home environment. Let’s delve into key considerations that can guide you to the right choice for your situation.

Level of Soil and Stains

Carpets can be magnets for dirt, spills, and various stains, transforming over time from plush comfort underfoot to a less appealing, stained surface. If your carpet is home to deep-seated dirt or has become a canvas for stubborn stains—from spilled wine to muddy footprints—the expertise of professional carpet cleaners to do a true deep carpet cleaning is invaluable.

These specialists employ hot water extraction and other powerful cleaning methods, designed to penetrate deep into carpet fibers and extract grime that typical DIY equipment simply can’t reach. For challenging cleaning tasks as well as ensuring that stains don't reappear, the thoroughness of a professional service is unmatched.

Carpet Type

Not all carpets are created equal. From luxurious, high-pile varieties to delicate antique rugs, each type demands a tailored approach to cleaning. Delicate carpets, especially, can be ruined by the wrong cleaning method or solution. Professionals have a deep understanding of different carpet materials and construction, ensuring they select the most appropriate and safe cleaning techniques. This expertise is particularly valuable for owners of carpets that require gentle, yet effective, care to preserve their beauty and integrity.


Budget considerations often sway homeowners towards a DIY approach. Renting a carpet cleaner and purchasing cleaning solutions can indeed be less expensive upfront compared to hiring a professional service. However, this initial savings may not tell the whole story.

DIY cleaning might not remove all the dirt and stains, potentially leading to the need for frequent cleanings or, worse, permanent damage that necessitates expensive repairs or replacement.

Professional cleaning, while costlier upfront, can extend the life of your carpet and may prove more economical in the long run.


Time and effort are precious commodities in today’s busy world. DIY carpet cleaning requires not just the rental of equipment and the research to understand how to do a thorough cleaning, but also the time spent on the actual cleaning—time that could be spent with family, on hobbies, or just relaxing.

Additionally, the process can be physically demanding and might not yield the desired results. In contrast, hiring professionals can offer peace of mind. Skilled technicians handle the entire process efficiently, freeing up your schedule and ensuring a level of cleanliness that contributes to a healthier living space.


close up of white carpet in a room

The choice between DIY and professional carpet cleaning boils down to a balance of factors: the condition and type of your carpets, your budget, and how much value you place on your time and peace of mind. While there’s a certain satisfaction in doing it yourself, the expertise, equipment, and efficiency professionals bring to the table can not only save you time but also protect and preserve your carpets in the long run.

Before making a decision, weigh these considerations carefully, aiming for the choice that best aligns with your needs and ensures your carpets remain a cherished part of your home.


Name E-mail Phone Number Message Submit