Contact Us 


Is It Cheaper to Clean Carpet or Replace?

Published March 24, 2024 by Green Kleaning Services, LLC

illustration of money and carpet cleaning


Have you ever looked at your carpet and wondered whether its best days are behind it? The dilemma of whether to give old carpets a deep clean or start fresh with a replacement is common among homeowners as well as business owners.

Signs Your Carpet Needs Attention

Choosing between engaging professional carpet cleaners or opting for a complete carpet replacement involves weighing various considerations.

This decision is necessary not just for the aesthetic appeal of your home but also for the health and comfort of its occupants.

See below for some of the indicators that suggest the need for either cleaning or replacement, aiding you in making an informed decision.

magnifying glass on a carpet

When To Opt For Professional Carpet Cleaning

Your carpet may not be at the end of its journey but could significantly benefit from a professional touch if you observe the following signs:

Persistent Stains

Spots from wine, pet mishaps, coffee, or ink that refuse to budge after home cleaning attempts signal the need for professional intervention. Expert carpet cleaners possess the tools and techniques to tackle these stubborn stains, restoring your carpet's appearance.

Lingering Odors

If a musty smell or pet odors persist even after thorough vacuuming and use of over-the-counter fresheners, it's a clear indication that odors have penetrated deep into the fibers or padding.

Professional cleaning can eliminate these deep-seated odors, leaving your carpet smelling fresh.

Dull Appearance in High-Traffic Areas

Carpets in hallways, living rooms, and other areas that see a lot of foot traffic can lose their vibrancy and texture over time. Professional cleaning can rejuvenate these areas, lifting dirt and restoring the carpet's original color and softness.

When To Completely Replace Old Carpet Altogether

There are instances, however, when a carpet has reached the point of no return, and replacement becomes necessary. Consider a new carpet if you're facing:

Irreversible Stains and Wear

When stains blend into the fabric of your carpet and become a fixed feature, or when visible pathways have been tread into its surface, these are signs that a good cleaning won't restore your carpet.

Similarly, rips, tears, or holes from furniture, pets, or accidents can't be remedied with cleaning.

Worn-Out Padding

The carpet padding beneath your carpet plays an important role in comfort and durability. Over time, if the padding becomes flat or starts to disintegrate, it can't support the carpet, leading to a need for replacement.

You might notice unevenness, hear crunching sounds, or feel less cushioning as you walk.

Age and Lack of Maintenance

Carpets typically have a lifespan of 10 to 15 years, depending on the quality and how well they're maintained.

If your carpet is over a decade old and hasn't received professional cleaning regularly, its age might have caught up with it, making replacement necessary.

Cost Considerations

Let's break down the costs associated with professional carpet cleaning and carpet replacement, employing a wide array of relevant keywords to guide you through the financial decision-making process.

illustration of costs for carpet cleaning

Professional Carpet Cleaning

Opting for professional carpet cleaning services is often viewed as a cost-efficient measure to rejuvenate your carpets.

While prices fluctuate based on the size of the area, the type of cleaning required (such as addressing tough stains, pet odors, or heavy foot traffic areas), and regional pricing differences, the investment is considerably lower than that of full replacement.

A couple of hundred dollars may make all the difference in the world.

Carpet Replacement

Conversely, the pathway to carpet replacement is paved with various costs that extend well beyond the initial price per square yard or square foot of the new carpet.

These additional expenses can include the labor for old carpet removal, disposal fees, and the often-overlooked cost of moving furniture.

Furthermore, the type of carpet chosen—be it luxury plush carpets, stain-resistant varieties, or eco-friendly options—can significantly affect the overall price tag, with costs ranging widely from $3 to $7 per square foot for mid-range carpet materials, not including installation fees.

Financial Takeaway

The decision between professional carpet cleaning and total carpet replacement hinges on a balanced consideration of cost, value, and long-term home maintenance goals.

In many scenarios, a carpet cleaned professionally emerges as the more economical and practical choice, especially for carpets that have maintained their structural integrity but need a refresh to eliminate stains, odors, or dullness.

Such an approach can breathe new life into your carpets, postponing the need for a costly replacement.

However, in cases where carpets are extensively damaged, show signs of mold or mildew, or have sustained irreparable wear and tear over many years, investing in new carpeting might be the more financially prudent option over the long haul.

New carpets can enhance the value and comfort of your home, eliminate health hazards associated with old, worn-out carpets, and provide a fresh start for your interior decor.

Health and Sustainability

Health Benefit Of Regular Carpet Cleanings

The choice to engage a professional carpet cleaner brings with it profound advantages for the indoor air quality of your home.

Carpet cleaning companies are adept at removing an array of allergens, pet dander, pollen, and even mold spores, which can deeply embed themselves in the fibers of your carpet.

For households with small children, individuals with allergies, or those with respiratory conditions, this reduction in allergens can make a huge difference.

Speaking of this demographic, choosing carpet cleaning companies that use safe and eco friendly products reduces further risk of adverse effects.

Regular cleanings ensure these irritants are meticulously removed, thus reducing the likelihood of allergic reactions, asthma flare-ups, and other respiratory issues.


From an environmental standpoint, the decision to maintain and clean your carpets rather than replace them can have a considerable impact. Carpet production is resource-intensive, involving not only the consumption of materials but also the energy required for manufacturing and transportation.

For those that are environmentally conscious it is worth noting that the disposal of old carpets contributes to landfill waste, where they can take decades to decompose, releasing potentially harmful chemicals into the environment.

By opting for regular carpet maintenance, homeowners can extend the life of their carpets, thereby reducing the demand for new carpets and lowering their environmental footprint.

Regular cleanings, careful vacuuming, and immediate attention to spills can prolong the durability and appearance of your carpet, making sustainability a practical benefit of choosing professional carpet care over replacement.


When weighing the options of cleaning versus replacing your carpet, consider the condition, cost implications, and the environmental and health benefits.

2 sides of a rug clean and uncleaned

For most, professional cleaning offers a cost-effective way to rejuvenate carpets, enhancing both their appearance and lifespan. However, for carpets beyond salvage, replacement might be the necessary choice.

Considering a refresh or a complete overhaul of your carpets? Start with a professional cleaning consultation to explore how you can breathe new life into your home's flooring.


Name E-mail Phone Number Message Submit